Home   »   UPSC Mains GS 2 Ques

Right to privacy is intrinsic to life and personal liberty and is inherently protected under Article 21 of the constitution. Explain. In this reference discuss the law relating to D.N.A testing of child in the womb to establish its paternity

Article 21 of the Indian Constitution states, “No person shall be deprived of his life or personal liberty except according to procedure established by law.” 

In the landmark case of Justice K.S. Puttaswamy vs. Union of India (2017), the Supreme Court of India affirmed that the right to privacy is intrinsic to life and personal liberty, thus making it a fundamental right under Article 21.

Right to privacy is Intrinsic to Article 21:

  • Personal liberty- it allows individuals to make their own decisions without interference from the state.
  • Bodily autonomy & integrity- This includes the right to make decisions concerning one’s body, health and reproductive choices without coercion or interference.
  • Informational choices– This refers to the right to control one’s personal data and prevent its unauthorized collection, use or disclosure..
  • Privacy of communication: The right to privacy ensures the confidentiality of personal communications, including phone calls, email  and letters. It safeguards individuals from unwarranted interception or monitoring of their communications.   
  • Balancing privacy and state interest (Puttaswamy judgement): Any invasion of life or personal liberty must meet the three requirements of 
    • legality, i.e. there must be a law in existence;
    • legitimate aim, includes goals like national security
    • proportionality of the legitimate aims with the object sought to be achieved.

DNA testing and Right to Privacy:

DNA testing, particularly for establishing paternity, intersects with the right to privacy and raises legal and ethical concerns. In cases where a child’s paternity is disputed, DNA testing is often seen as a scientifically accurate method to resolve such issues. However, this involves sensitive personal data, including genetic material, which falls under the purview of privacy rights.

Laws relating to D.N.A testing of Child: 

  1. DNA technology(Use & Application) Regulation Bill, 2019–  establishes a DNA data bank to identify the identity of the individual in case of paternity disputes as well.
  2. Prenatal Diagnostic Techniques (PNDT) Act, 1994:

The PNDT Act regulates the use of prenatal diagnostic techniques, particularly to prevent misuse of such tests for sex determination. This law emphasizes privacy protections, ensuring that genetic testing, including DNA tests, cannot be misused for purposes that violate an individual’s dignity.

  1. K.S Puttaswamy Case (2017)– SC affirmed Right to privacy as Intrinsic part under Article 21, wherein (a) Legality- restriction must be backed by law; (b) Legitimacy- state must have a valid interest that justifies limitation on privacy; (c)Proportionality- careful balancing where benefits are weighed against its impact on the individual. 
  2. Pre-Conception & Pre- Natal Diagnostic Technique Act, 1994– it bans sex determination but can also indirectly be applied to paternity testing.
  3. Aparna Ajinkya Firodia v. Ajinkya Arun Firodia (2023): The Supreme Court emphasized that DNA tests should not be used to satisfy mere suspicion but only when strong prima facie evidence of infidelity exists. It also stressed the need to consider the child’s best interests.
  4. Nandlal Wasudeo Badwaik v. Lata Nandlal Badwaik (2014): The Supreme Court held that DNA tests could be ordered if crucial to resolving paternity disputes, but the child’s welfare and the mother’s privacy must be safeguarded.
  5. Dipanwita Roy v. Ronobroto Roy (2014): The Supreme Court upheld the wife’s right to refuse a DNA test,emphasizing that compelling her would violate her privacy and bodily integrity.

Conclusion 

While DNA testing can be a tool for determining paternity, it must be balanced against the fundamental right to privacy. Any infringement upon this right must be justified by a compelling state interest, making it necessary to ensure that such tests are conducted only in exceptional circumstances.

Related Post
UPSC Mains GS 1 Question Paper 2024 UPSC Mains GS 1 Analysis 2024
UPSC Mains Essay Question Paper 2024 UPSC Mains Essay Analysis 2024
UPSC Mains GS 2 Question Paper 2024

Sharing is caring!

About the Author
Piyush
Piyush
Author

Greetings! I'm Piyush, a content writer at StudyIQ. I specialize in creating enlightening content focused on UPSC and State PSC exams. Let's embark on a journey of discovery, where we unravel the intricacies of these exams and transform aspirations into triumphant achievements together!

TOPICS: