Table of Contents
Context:
- The Supreme Court has affirmed that Pollution Control Boards (PCBs) have the authority, under the Water Act and Air Act, to levy environmental compensation on polluting entities.
- A bench of Justices P.S. Narasimha and Manoj Misra clarified that PCBs may seek restitutionary or compensatory damages either through fixed monetary penalties or bank guarantees, serving as preventive measures to avert potential environmental damage.
Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB)
Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) is a statutory body constituted in 1974, under the Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1974. It is also entrusted with the powers and functions under the Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1981.
Objectives
- To monitor and control pollution in the air and water.
- To advise the Central Government on matters concerning the prevention and control of pollution.
- To coordinate the activities of the State Pollution Control Boards (SPCBs).
- To conduct research and development on pollution issues.
- To lay down national standards for environmental quality.
Functions
- Preventing, controlling and abating water pollution
- Preventing, controlling, and abating air pollution & Improving air quality.
- Advising the central government on water and air pollution
Pollution Control Boards (PCBs) Statutory Authority to Levy Compensation
- Supreme Court expanded the powers of Pollution Control Boards (PCBs).
- PCBs can impose and collect restitutionary and compensatory damages to restore polluted air and water bodies.
- May demand fixed monetary sums or bank guarantees as preventive (ex-ante) measures under:
- Section 33A, Water Act, 1974
- Section 31A, Air Act, 1981
Scope and Limits
- Compensation is not for every statutory violation.
- Applicable only when:
- Environmental damage has occurred, or
- Damage is imminent.
- Must first frame subordinate legislation (rules/regulations) under both Acts.
- Rules must follow natural justice and fair process before imposing compensation.
Jurisprudence Supporting the Ruling
- Based on Vellore Citizens Welfare Forum (1996) and Indian Council for Enviro-Legal Action (1996).
- These cases established environmental restitution as a constitutional and statutory duty, distinct from punitive measures.
Principles Laid Down by the Court
1. Remedial vs Punitive
- Restitutionary compensation = preventive/remedial
- Fines/imprisonment = punitive, require judicial procedure.
2. Non-punitive nature
Monetary compensation for environmental damage is not punitive if imposed under regulatory powers.
3. Polluter Pays Principle applies when
- Environmental thresholds breached, causing damage.
- Damage occurs even without threshold breaches.
- Significant environmental risks were identified, irrespective of breaches.
4. Preventive duty
PCBs must act proactively (ex-ante) even without proven damage.
Broad Mandate and Responsibilities
- PCBs have wide powers under the Water & Air Acts to:
- Shut down industries.
- Stop essential services.
- Issue remedial directions.
- Linked to the State’s constitutional duty under Article 51A to protect the environment.
- Emphasised the importance of air and water protection amid the climate crisis.
Strengthening Remedial Jurisprudence
- Expansion of the right to a clean environment requires strong remedial powers.
- Injunctions or compensation alone are inadequate.
- Restitutionary measures to restore ecosystems must be a core part of environmental enforcement.
Features of New Classification of Industries
- Industries are classified into 5 categories according to their pollution potential.
- A new category, called the “Blue Category”, has been introduced specifically for industries that provide Essential Environmental Services (EES).
- It includes industries or utilities essential for environmental management, such as:
- Waste-to-Energy plants
- Certain Compressed Biogas (CBG) plants
- Landfill maintenance services
- Biomining operations
- Extended Validity: Industries in the Blue category will receive an additional 2 years of validity for their Consent to Operate (CTO), as an incentive.
Criteria and Examples of Industries
Industry | Pollution Index (PI) Range | Examples |
🔴 Red | PI > 80 | Thermal power plants, Cement manufacturing, Tanneries |
🟠 Orange | 55 ≤ PI < 80 | Brick manufacturing, Dry cell batteries, coal washeries etc. |
🟢 Green | 25 ≤ PI < 55 | Ice cream manufacturing, Assembly units (non-polluting) |
⚪ White | PI < 25 | Solar power generation, Medical oxygen etc. |
🔵 Blue | Variable PI | Waste to Energy plants, Landfill operators, CBG plants |
Recent Initiatives by CPCB
- Launch of Sameer App for real-time air quality updates.
- Implementation of Graded Response Action Plan (GRAP) in Delhi-NCR.
- Guidelines on e-waste, plastic waste, and biomedical waste management.